
Scott Derrickson’s latest film, “The Gorge,” released on Apple TV+ on February 14, 2025, is a curious and ambitious genre mash-up that blends sci-fi, horror, action, and romance into a unique cinematic experience. Starring Miles Teller and Anya Taylor-Joy as two highly-trained operatives guarding a mysterious abyss, the film has garnered a mixed yet often positive reception, particularly for its strong lead performances and its surprising exploration of character psyche and connection amidst a world of lurking evil.
The premise is intriguing: Levi (Miles Teller) and Drasa (Anya Taylor-Joy) are assigned to solitary guard towers on opposite sides of a vast, highly classified gorge, tasked with protecting the world from a mysterious evil within. Forbidden from direct communication, their year-long assignment becomes a test of isolation, duty, and an unexpected burgeoning connection.
The Psyche of Isolation and Connection
“The Gorge” delves into the psychological impact of isolation and the profound human need for connection. Levi, a battle-hardened former U.S. Marine, carries emotional scars from his past, hinted at through his stoic demeanor. Drasa, a vibrant and skilled sniper from Eastern Europe, contrasts his quiet intensity. Despite the physical distance and strict rules, their tentative interactions across the gorge – initially through binoculars and later through shared moments of vulnerability – become the film’s beating heart. This slow-burn development of their relationship is frequently cited as the film’s most compelling aspect, building a believable and endearing romance that defies the high-stakes, monstrous backdrop.
Reviewers note that the film excels at showing, rather than just telling, the characters’ inner lives. Their shared isolation and the constant threat from the “Hollow Men” (creatures emerging from the gorge) force them to confront their deepest fears and desires for companionship. The film subtly explores themes of loneliness, duty, and the human capacity to form bonds even in the most extreme circumstances. The chemistry between Teller and Taylor-Joy is a consistent highlight, their performances lending depth to characters who, on paper, might seem thinly sketched. Their ability to convey emotion and build a relationship with minimal dialogue is a testament to their acting prowess.
Genre Blending and Visuals
Derrickson, known for his work in horror and supernatural thrillers (“Sinister,” “The Black Phone”), infuses “The Gorge” with a palpable sense of dread and mystery. The gorge itself is depicted as a visually stunning yet ominous entity, with atmospheric cinematography by Dan Laustsen (known for his work with Guillermo del Toro). The creature designs for the “Hollow Men” are described as “evocative & creepy,” adding a genuine horror element to the proceedings. The action sequences are well-staged and visually engaging, benefiting from a propulsive score by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross.
However, the film’s ambitious genre-blending is also a source of some criticism. Some reviewers felt the transitions between romance, sci-fi, and action were not always smooth, leading to a “tonally uneven” experience. The narrative, while intriguing, is occasionally described as “implausible” or “preposterous,” with some plot holes that stretch credibility. The shift from a character-driven mystery in the first half to a more action-heavy second half was noted by some as a point where the film loses some of its initial intrigue.
Conclusion: A Flawed Yet Engaging Experience
“The Gorge” is not a perfect film, and its ambitious scope occasionally leads to narrative inconsistencies. However, it stands out for its earnest exploration of human connection in extraordinary circumstances. Miles Teller and Anya Taylor-Joy deliver strong performances, creating a believable and engaging central relationship that anchors the film. For audiences willing to embrace its unique blend of genres and overlook some narrative shortcuts, “The Gorge” offers a thrilling, atmospheric, and surprisingly heartfelt cinematic experience that delves into the deeper psychological needs of its characters. It’s a testament to the power of human connection, even at the edge of an abyss.


